Australia won the toss and chose to bat at Sydney on 2 December 1932. Bradman, exhausted and unwell, had been ruled out on the eve of the Test. Bill Woodfull, Bill Ponsford and Jack Fingleton fell to disciplined English seam bowling, and McCabe walked in at 3 for 82 to face the new Bodyline attack of Larwood, Voce and Bowes with a packed leg-side cordon.
McCabe's response was to attack. He hooked off the front foot, off the back foot, off short balls and off length balls, three consecutive fours off Larwood's first spell taking him to 30. After three boundaries against Gubby Allen — who refused on principle to bowl Bodyline — Jardine reset the field and Larwood resumed leg-theory. McCabe kept hooking. By stumps on day one he was 127 not out from 173 balls; Australia were 7 for 296.
On day two he added 60 of the last 70 runs Australia made, in just under an hour, finishing 187 not out from 233 balls with 25 fours, when Tim Wall was dismissed and Australia all out for 360. He had instructed his father in the dressing room: 'If I get hit, Dad, don't jump the fence.'
England replied with 524 (Sutcliffe 194, Hammond 112). Australia, again without Bradman, made only 164 in their second innings, and England won by ten wickets. But the McCabe innings became the moral spine of Australia's bodyline summer. He had shown the response was not impossible, only extraordinarily dangerous. Bradman would adapt his own response — backing away to leg, cutting square — across the rest of the series. McCabe's innings was Australian cricket telling England that bodyline could be batted, even if at appalling personal cost.