Shane Warne's first delivery in Ashes cricket on June 4, 1993, at Old Trafford is universally regarded as the greatest ball ever bowled. But what makes it qualify for this list is the reaction — specifically, Mike Gatting's face. The expression of utter bewilderment, confusion, and existential crisis on Gatting's face as he looked at his shattered stumps has provided cricket fans with decades of entertainment. It was the facial equivalent of watching a man discover that the laws of physics had been temporarily suspended.
The ball pitched well outside leg stump — where no sane batsman would worry about being bowled — and then spun so dramatically that it clipped the top of off stump. The angle of deviation was so extreme that it seemed to violate the basic principles of ball dynamics. It was as if the ball had started its journey heading to Birmingham and arrived in Manchester, having changed direction mid-flight for reasons that remain unclear to this day.
Gatting played a textbook forward defensive shot to where the ball should have been — where every coaching manual, every physics textbook, and every instinct developed over 30 years of cricket told him the ball would be. His technique was perfect. The ball simply wasn't where physics said it should be. His head turned slowly to look at the stumps behind him, then back at where the ball had pitched, then at Warne, then at the umpire, in a sequence of disbelief that resembled a man who'd just seen a magic trick and was checking for hidden wires.
Richie Benaud's commentary — "Gatting has absolutely no idea what has happened to him, and he still doesn't know" — perfectly captured the moment with the kind of understated brilliance that made Benaud himself a legend. The line was as perfect as the delivery it described.
Warne later said he couldn't have bowled that ball again if he'd tried a thousand times. The delivery turned Warne from an unknown chubby leg-spinner with bleached hair into a global superstar in a single moment. And Gatting's face became a meme decades before memes were invented — the universal expression of bewilderment that transcended cricket and became part of popular culture.