Player Clashes

William Martingell — Surrey's Roundarm Seamer Joins the UAEE Breakaway, 1852

1852-08-15Surrey, United All-England ElevenWilliam Martingell's career for Surrey and the United All-England Eleven, 1839–18652 min readSeverity: Mild

Summary

William Martingell of Nutfield, Surrey, was one of the leading roundarm bowlers in England through the late 1840s and 1850s. When Wisden and Dean broke from Clarke's All-England Eleven in 1852, Martingell was among the first professionals to join the new United All-England Eleven, citing Clarke's autocratic management and inadequate pay — a decision that cost him several AEE fixtures but confirmed the UAEE's credibility.

Background

Clarke's flat match fee left professionals unable to share in the large gate receipts of popular fixtures. The senior southern bowlers — Wisden, Dean, Martingell — had the most to gain from the UAEE's profit-sharing model.

What Happened

William Martingell was born at Nutfield, Surrey, in 1818 and made his first-class debut in 1839. A right-arm medium-fast roundarm bowler who could also bat usefully, he was a regular in the Surrey side through the 1840s and early 1850s, taking 659 first-class wickets at 14.96 across 195 matches. His best performance was 8 for 53 for Surrey against Nottinghamshire at Trent Bridge in 1850. When Wisden and Dean formed the UAEE in August 1852, Martingell was among the southerners they recruited; his membership confirmed that the new body was not merely a personal vehicle for two malcontents but a genuine professional alternative. Clarke blackballed him from AEE matches as a result. Martingell continued to play for the UAEE through the 1850s alongside his regular Surrey duties, and was a key figure in Surrey's champion county years. He retired in 1865 and died at Nutfield in 1897, aged 78.

Key Moments

1

1818: Martingell born at Nutfield, Surrey

2

1839: First-class debut

3

1850: Career-best 8/53 for Surrey v Nottinghamshire at Trent Bridge

4

Aug 1852: Joins UAEE at formation

5

1852–56: Banned from AEE fixtures by Clarke

6

1865: Retires from first-class cricket

7

1897: Dies at Nutfield

Aftermath

Clarke's blackball of UAEE members cost the AEE several of its most effective bowlers. Martingell continued uninterrupted with Surrey through the 1850s, and after Clarke's death in 1856 the ban was lifted.

⚖️ The Verdict

Martingell's decision to join the UAEE split gave the rebel body the credibility of a proven first-class bowler and deepened Clarke's difficulty in maintaining a dominant roster.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Martingell and Clarke ever reconcile?
Clarke died in August 1856 without lifting the ban; his successor George Parr ended the boycott and Martingell played in AEE fixtures again from 1857.

Related Incidents