Grace turned 50 on 18 July 1898. The MCC committee, including Lord Harris and Lord Hawke, scheduled the year's flagship Gentlemen v Players fixture to start on his birthday at Lord's; tickets sold out in advance. The Prince of Wales attended on day one. The Gentlemen XI included Grace as captain plus C.B. Fry, Stanley Jackson, Ranjitsinhji, A.E. Stoddart and Gilbert Jessop; the Players included Tom Hayward, Bobby Abel, J.T. Hearne and Wilfred Rhodes. Grace, hampered by lameness and a hand injury picked up earlier in the summer, batted at three. He was applauded all the way to the wicket on day one, and again on day two; he made 43 and 31 not out, a modest contribution by his own standards but received with sustained ovations.
The match was drawn — rain and a defensive Players second-innings batting display ran the time out. Grace was presented with a commemorative gold watch by the MCC committee at the close, and birthday telegrams were read out from across the cricketing Empire. The London papers gave the match more column inches than any cricket fixture of the year apart from the Tests themselves.
Four days later, on 22 July, Grace went to Trent Bridge for Gloucestershire's Championship match against Nottinghamshire. He scored 168, his highest first-class score of the season, and the Trent Bridge crowd produced a similar standing ovation. He continued playing first-class cricket for another decade, finally retiring from London County matches in 1908 at the age of 60.