Umpiring Controversies

The Original Mankad — Vinoo Mankad, 1947

13-17 December 1947Australia vs India2nd Test, India tour of Australia1 min readSeverity: Moderate

Summary

Vinoo Mankad ran out Bill Brown at the non-striker's end during India's tour of Australia, creating a dismissal type that would bear his name for decades.

What Happened

During India's tour of Australia in 1947-48, Indian all-rounder Vinoo Mankad ran out Australian opener Bill Brown at the non-striker's end. This was not the first instance of such a dismissal, but it became the most famous because Mankad had previously warned Brown about backing up too far.

In the tour match before the Test, Mankad had already run Brown out in the same manner. Despite the warning, Brown continued to leave his crease early. In the second Test, Mankad did it again, this time in a match situation.

The Australian media criticized Mankad, but interestingly, the great Don Bradman himself defended the Indian, saying the batsman was at fault for leaving his crease. Bradman's position was clear: the Laws existed to be enforced, and the batsman was gaining an unfair advantage.

The dismissal became known as "Mankading" and remained one of cricket's most debated areas for over 70 years, until the ICC normalized it as a standard run-out in 2022. Every subsequent instance — from Ashwin-Buttler to Deepti Sharma — traces back to this original moment.

⚖️ The Verdict

Legal dismissal even then. Don Bradman supported Mankad. The term 'Mankading' persisted until ICC renamed it a standard run-out in 2022.

Related Incidents