Royle was 24 in 1879, an Oxford Blue (1875, 1876) and Lancashire amateur, on Lord Harris's tour as one of the strongest amateur fielders in England. His cover point fielding was famous: ambidextrous, quick across the ground, with a deadly accurate throw. Tom Emmett, calling his partner back for a single during a tour match, said 'Woa, mate, there's a policeman' — meaning Royle in the covers, as immovable as a constable. At Melbourne in January 1879, Royle came in at first wicket down for England's first innings and was bowled by Spofforth — the first wicket of the first Test hat-trick. He scored 3 in the second innings and never played another Test. He returned to England, was ordained, and became headmaster of Stanmore Park school, where he served until his death in 1929. His one-Test legacy is the combination of two extreme firsts: greatest fielder of his era, and first victim of a Test hat-trick.