Garrett was a Newington College schoolboy product who had played first-grade Sydney cricket since 16. His selection for the All-Australian XI surprised the press but reflected a chronic shortage of fast bowlers willing to play. He opened the bowling with John Hodges, took two wickets in each innings, and made 18 not out and 0 with the bat. The 18-not-out shared a 43-run last-wicket stand with Bannerman that significantly extended Australia's first-innings total. Garrett's age — 18 years 232 days — has never been bettered for Australia in an England Test, despite the youth-promotion eras of the 1990s and 2010s. He toured England in 1878, 1882 and 1886, played a further 18 Tests, and finished his career with 36 wickets at 26.95. After cricket he was a successful Sydney solicitor and captained NSW to Sheffield Shields in the 1890s. He died in 1943 as Australia's last surviving first-Test cricketer.