The ICC's 2017 decision to grant Test status to Ireland and Afghanistan — bringing the number of Test-playing nations to twelve — was celebrated as expansion of cricket's reach but questioned by those who argued both nations lacked the infrastructure, depth, and competitive quality for the longest format.
Ireland and Afghanistan had both made remarkable progress through ICC Associate cricket. Ireland had defeated Pakistan in the 2007 World Cup (one of cricket's great upsets) and consistently competitive in ODI cricket. Afghanistan's rise from a refugee nation's cricket programme to ICC Full Member in 15 years was cricket's most remarkable development story.
The 2014 governance controversy had made the ICC politically committed to demonstrating broad membership value. Granting Test status was a tangible benefit to Associate members that did not cost Full Members commercially.
The ICC's decision was made at its June 2017 annual conference in London. Zimbabwe had retained Test status despite a decade of poor results and administrative chaos — the precedent that performance was not a prerequisite for Test status was well-established.
The BCCI and Cricket Australia were reportedly unenthusiastic but did not actively oppose. The ECB supported Ireland's application, which had political dimensions (Northern Ireland, the domestic cricket structure).
In June 2017, the ICC announced that Ireland and Afghanistan would be granted Full Member status, giving both nations Test cricket playing rights. Ireland played their inaugural Test against Pakistan in May 2018 at Malahide; Afghanistan played their inaugural Test against India in June 2018 at Bengaluru. The decision was partly driven by cricket's ICC governance reforms following the 2014 Big Three controversy — the ICC needed to demonstrate commitment to cricket's global growth. Critics argued that neither nation had a genuine first-class structure capable of producing Test-standard players consistently; that Tests against the weaker nations would be commercially unviable; and that the move diluted Test cricket's brand value. Supporters argued that exclusivity had no place in cricket's global development.
June 22, 2017: ICC grants Full Member status to Ireland and Afghanistan
May 2018: Ireland play inaugural Test vs Pakistan at Malahide, Dublin
June 2018: Afghanistan play inaugural Test vs India in Bengaluru
2019: Afghanistan's Rashid Khan and Mujeeb ur Rahman establish themselves as world-class bowlers
2022: Ireland and Afghanistan remain lowest-ranked Test teams by results; debate continues
2007
Ireland beat Pakistan in WC — signal of Associate cricket's quality
2010-2015
Both nations' rapid rise through ICC Associate structure
June 2017
Full Member status granted; Test rights confirmed
May-June 2018
Ireland and Afghanistan play inaugural Tests
“This is a historic day for cricket. Ireland and Afghanistan have earned the right to Test cricket through their performances and their commitment to the game.”
“It is the proudest day in Irish cricket history. We have worked so hard to reach this level. Test cricket is what we have always aspired to.”
“Afghanistan's spinners at their best are world-class. The decision to grant them Test status was right.”
Afghanistan's Test programme was severely disrupted from 2021 when the Taliban banned women's cricket, prompting ICC to reduce their international programme and suspend qualification for the Women's T20 World Cup. The full consequences for their Test status remained being assessed.
Ireland played only occasional Tests against willing opponents — most major nations were reluctant to schedule Test series with little commercial value. Their Test programme remained underdeveloped relative to the 2017 promise.
Both Ireland and Afghanistan have played Test cricket and provided competitive results — Afghanistan's spin bowling in particular at international level. However, their Test programmes remain limited in frequency and commercial value. The question of whether Test status accelerated or hindered their development remains genuinely contested.
The 2017 expansion reflected genuine cricket growth in two very different nations — Ireland's gradual development, Afghanistan's extraordinary rise. Whether Test status was the right tool for their development at that specific moment is still debated by cricket administrators globally.
ICC vs Cricket World
2005-07-07
The Super Sub rule, introduced in 2005, allowed ODI teams to replace one player mid-match — creating a massive tactical imbalance that rewarded the toss winner and was abandoned within 18 months as one of cricket's most embarrassing regulatory failures.
ICC vs Cricket Community
2016-06-01
The ICC's 2016 proposal to divide Test cricket into two tiers — with promotion and relegation — was opposed so ferociously by India, the BCCI, and virtually every player that it was abandoned before implementation, but the debate it sparked about Test cricket's future continues.
ICC vs Bowlers Worldwide
2020-07-08
The ICC's temporary COVID-era ban on using saliva to shine the cricket ball became permanent in 2022, eliminating a century-old ball-maintenance practice and permanently disadvantaging bowlers — a decision that continues to divide the sport.