Studd had made a century in each innings against the Australians for Cambridge earlier in the summer and was widely regarded as the best amateur batsman in England. Why captain AN Hornby left him at number 10 and Peate at 11 has never been satisfactorily explained. Some accounts blame nerves: Studd is said to have been wrapped in a blanket in the pavilion shaking with cold and tension. Others put the order down to Hornby's stubbornness or a misjudgement of when wickets would fall.
When Peate walked in, England were 75/9 and needed 10 to win. He took strike to Boyle, swung the first ball to leg for two, played and missed at the second, and was clean bowled by the third. England 77 all out, Australia winners by 7 runs. Studd, padded up, never faced a ball.
In the dressing room, when Peate was admonished for swinging instead of pushing for a single to put Studd on strike, the Yorkshireman is reputed to have said, 'I couldn't trust Mr Studd.' The class subtext was unmistakable: a 25-year-old professional from Holbeck telling his amateur teammates that he'd rather take responsibility himself than rely on a public-school man under pressure.