Stoddart had been one of the leading English batsmen of the 1890s, captain of the 1894-95 Ashes-winning tour and scorer of the 173 at Melbourne. He returned to Australia in November 1897 as captain of a strong England side. Within days of arrival the news of his mother's death reached him by telegram; she had died unexpectedly in London.
Stoddart was, by the testimony of his teammates, devastated. He withdrew from the First Test at Sydney; Archie MacLaren took over, and Ranji played his great 175 (see entry). Stoddart also missed the Second Test at Melbourne, where Australia regained the Ashes. He returned for the Third Test at Adelaide, made 17 and 24, and for the Fourth at Melbourne, made 9 and 25. The Sydney crowd at the dead-rubber Fifth Test barracked him heavily for slow scoring; he made 17.
Stoddart's 1897-98 series average was 11.83 across four innings — the worst of his career. He returned to England via the slow steamer route and effectively retired from first-class cricket in 1900. He worked as Secretary of Queen's Club, accumulated debts, and shot himself in his St John's Wood bedroom on 4 April 1915, aged 52. His grave in Radford, Coventry, was unmarked until 1956.