Herbie Taylor's South Africans had toured England with reasonable expectations after their competitive 1922-23 series at home. They won the toss at Edgbaston on a green-tinged early-summer pitch and chose to bat. Within 75 minutes they were all out for 30 — Gilligan's outswing and Tate's late-swinging fast-medium proved utterly unplayable. Gilligan finished with 6 for 7 in 6.3 overs; Tate took 4 for 12 in 6.
England replied with 438, Sutcliffe 64, Hobbs 76 and Hendren 74; their only century-maker was Frank Woolley with 134 not out at number five. South Africa fought back in their second innings, Bob Catterall making 120 and Jock Cameron 51, but the deficit was too great. England won by an innings and 18 runs.
Tate's emergence as a Test bowler was the more important narrative of the summer. He had moved from gentle off-spin to brisk fast-medium in 1922 on the advice of his Sussex captain Gilligan; by 1924 he was the most accurate swing bowler in England. The series gave him 27 wickets in five Tests at 15.7. Across the next four years he would be the principal English Test bowler, finishing the 1924-25 Ashes with 38 wickets.