Umpire Darrell Hair called Muttiah Muralitharan for throwing seven times during the Boxing Day Test, igniting one of cricket's longest-running controversies.
Muttaiah Muralitharan was born with a unique physiological condition — a congenital deformity of the elbow joint that prevented him from fully straightening his arm. This meant that his bowling action, which appeared to flex and straighten through the delivery stride, was not the result of cheating but of anatomy. To Murali, the action felt perfectly natural; to those unfamiliar with his condition, it looked like throwing.
When Sri Lanka toured Australia for the 1995-96 Boxing Day Test at the MCG, Murali was already recognised as one of the most extraordinary spin bowlers in the world — an off-spinner capable of turning the ball prodigiously on any surface and generating previously unseen deliveries. He had taken 104 Test wickets and was seen as Sri Lanka's match-winner.
Darrell Hair was a highly regarded Australian umpire known for his forthright manner and unwillingness to be pressured. Hair had formed a view about Murali's action and arrived at the MCG prepared to act on it. What followed would define both men's careers and set cricket on a path toward fundamental rule changes.
The Boxing Day Test began routinely enough. Sri Lanka, playing in Australia, were underdogs but capable of producing upsets. Murali had bowled without incident in previous matches on the tour without being called. The MCG, one of the world's great cricket arenas, was packed with tens of thousands of fans expecting a festival of cricket.
When Murali came on to bowl, Hair watched his action carefully. After a few deliveries, he made his decision — calling Murali for throwing with a raised bent arm, the signal for a no-ball for a throwing action. The ground fell silent. Players on both teams looked on in disbelief. Hair called Murali seven times in the over.
The Sri Lankan dressing room erupted in fury. Captain Arjuna Ranatunga was incensed, confronting the umpires and signalling his utter contempt for the decision. Murali himself appeared stunned — he had never been called before and had no way of changing an action dictated by his own skeleton. The humiliation was public, profound, and broadcast to millions worldwide.
On Boxing Day 1995 at the MCG, Australian umpire Darrell Hair called Muttiah Muralitharan for throwing seven times during the 2nd Test. It was the first time a bowler had been called for throwing in a Test match since the 1960s and it ignited one of cricket's most enduring controversies.
Sri Lanka were outraged, viewing Hair's actions as racially motivated and an attack on Murali's unique bowling action, which involved a hyperextended elbow that created the illusion of throwing. Sri Lankan cricket officials, players, and fans united in condemning Hair. The incident triggered years of biomechanical testing, rule changes, and debates about bowling actions.
Subsequent scientific testing showed that Murali's elbow was naturally deformed and could not be straightened, meaning what looked like throwing was actually his natural action. The ICC eventually changed the rules to allow up to 15 degrees of elbow extension for all bowlers. Murali went on to become the highest wicket-taker in Test history with 800 wickets. Hair's decision at the MCG, while made in good faith, sparked a controversy that took nearly a decade to fully resolve and permanently altered how bowling actions were assessed.
Murali comes on to bowl at the MCG — Hair watches his action intently from the bowler's end
Hair raises his bent arm — calling Murali for throwing. First time in a Test match since the 1960s
Hair calls Murali seven times in the same over — Murali is visibly shocked and humiliated
Captain Ranatunga confronts the umpires — Sri Lanka are furious, viewing the action as racially motivated
Biomechanical testing later confirms Murali cannot straighten his arm due to a congenital defect
ICC amends the Laws to allow 15 degrees of elbow flexion — Murali is cleared to bowl
26 December 1995
Murali comes on to bowl at the MCG in the Boxing Day Test
First over
Darrell Hair calls Murali for throwing — seven times in one over. Unprecedented.
Immediately after
Captain Ranatunga confronts umpires — Sri Lanka lodge official protest
1995–1996
Biomechanical testing at University of Western Australia confirms congenital deformity
2004
ICC amends Laws to allow 15 degrees of elbow flexion — Murali fully cleared
2010
Murali retires with 800 Test wickets — cricket's all-time record
“I can't straighten my arm. It is physically impossible. I have never thrown in my life. This was one of the most humiliating days of my career.”
“I called what I saw. I believed his action was illegal. That is an umpire's job. I stand by the decision I made.”
“The biomechanics are unambiguous. His elbow does not straighten. What looks like throwing is the natural consequence of his unique anatomy.”
“Eight hundred Test wickets. The greatest bowler who ever lived. And they called him a cheat. Let that sink in.”
The immediate aftermath was explosive. Sri Lanka officially protested to the ICC and Cricket Australia. The Sri Lankan board called Hair's actions racially and culturally motivated — a charge that Hair strongly denied, insisting he was applying the Laws as he saw them. The incident dominated headlines worldwide and divided the cricket community.
Scientific testing was subsequently commissioned. Biomechanical analysis at the University of Western Australia and later at Cardiff Metropolitan University confirmed that Murali's elbow was congenitally deformed — he physically could not straighten it. The 'throwing' effect was an optical illusion created by the rotation of his wrist through the delivery, not by a genuine straightening of the elbow. The evidence was presented to the ICC.
Hair continued to umpire at the highest level but found himself at the centre of controversy again — most notably in 2006 when he and Billy Doctrove forfeited the Oval Test against Pakistan over ball tampering allegations. His relationship with the ICC became increasingly strained, and he eventually left the elite panel. His career was forever linked to the Murali controversy.
Hair was within his rights but the action was highly controversial. ICC eventually changed rules to allow 15 degrees of elbow extension. Murali took 800 Test wickets.
The Murali-Hair controversy was one of cricket's most consequential disputes. It directly led to the ICC adopting the 15-degree elbow flexion rule in 2004, which acknowledged the biomechanical reality that most fast bowlers exceed the previous tolerance threshold. The rule change effectively cleared Murali and reset the framework for assessing bowling actions worldwide.
For Murali personally, the controversy was a source of profound pain. He spent years being questioned, tested, and doubted despite evidence that supported his innocence. He channelled that pain into extraordinary performance, taking 800 Test wickets — a record that stands to this day and that many regard as cricket's most remarkable individual achievement. From a man who was called a cheat at the MCG in 1995, he became cricket's greatest wicket-taker. The vindication was complete, even if the scars remained.
Australia vs Pakistan
22 November 1981
Dennis Lillee kicked Javed Miandad on the field, prompting Miandad to raise his bat as if to strike Lillee. Umpire Tony Crafter intervened to separate them.
New Zealand vs West Indies
12 February 1980
Michael Holding kicked the stumps out of the ground in frustration after an LBW appeal was turned down against John Parker.
West Indies vs Australia
28 April 1995
Curtly Ambrose got in Steve Waugh's face after being told to go back to his mark. Richie Richardson had to pull Ambrose away. Ambrose then bowled a devastating spell.