Michael Slater claimed a low catch to dismiss Sachin Tendulkar, but replays suggested the ball had bounced before reaching his hands. The on-field decision was out.
During the first Test between India and Australia at Chennai in 1998, Michael Slater claimed a low catch at slip to dismiss Sachin Tendulkar. The on-field umpire gave Tendulkar out, but replays appeared to show the ball bouncing before it reached Slater's hands.
Tendulkar walked off reluctantly, and the Indian team was frustrated. In the pre-DRS era, there was no mechanism to challenge the decision. The controversy was compounded by the fact that Tendulkar had been batting well and looked set for a big score.
The incident highlighted the difficulty of judging low catches in real time — a problem that would persist even into the DRS era with the soft signal controversy. Slip catches taken close to the ground are among the hardest decisions in cricket for both on-field and TV umpires.
Slater maintained he took the catch cleanly. But the inconclusive replays fueled the debate about whether fielders should be given the benefit of the doubt in catch decisions.
Given out. No review available. The catch remains disputed among Indian cricket fans.
Gujarat Titans vs Rajasthan Royals
29 May 2026
The Qualifier 2 toss between Gujarat Titans and Rajasthan Royals at Mullanpur had to be conducted twice after match referee Prakash Bhatt failed to hear Riyan Parag's call — a visible frustration for Shubman Gill who appeared to have won the original toss before the do-over.
Lucknow Super Giants vs Kolkata Knight Riders
26 April 2026
Kartik Tyagi bowled two beamers in the final over of LSG's chase but was allowed to continue — umpires called only one dangerous — sparking IPL fury.
Various county and representative sides
1864-06-01
The legalisation of overarm bowling in 1864 created an immediate grey zone: how high could the arm go, and at what point did a fast delivery become an illegal throw? Through the 1860s English cricket struggled with this question as a succession of fast bowlers developed actions that umpires suspected but rarely no-balled, creating a climate of suspicion that would recur in every generation of cricket thereafter.