Top Controversies

Ireland and Afghanistan Granted Test Status

22 June 2017Ireland and AfghanistanICC Full Membership Decision5 min readSeverity: Moderate

Summary

The ICC granted Full Membership and Test status to Ireland and Afghanistan in 2017, but the lack of guaranteed fixtures and the challenges of sustaining Test cricket raised questions about whether the expansion was genuine or merely symbolic.

Background

The grant of full member status — and with it Test playing rights — to Ireland and Afghanistan by the International Cricket Council in June 2017 was the most significant expansion of the Test-playing community in seventeen years, since Bangladesh's elevation in 2000. The two boards' admission was the product of long campaigns conducted in very different circumstances. Ireland had been the most successful Associate side of the early twenty-first century, qualifying for three consecutive World Cups, beating Pakistan and England at global tournaments, and producing senior international cricketers in Eoin Morgan, Ed Joyce and Boyd Rankin who had been lost to England under residency rules. Afghanistan's rise was more recent and arguably more remarkable, the side having graduated from the World Cricket League's lowest divisions through five promotions in a decade to become a senior international side, with much of its programme conducted in exile in the UAE due to the security situation at home. The 2014 'Big Three' restructuring of the ICC, which had concentrated revenue and decision-making in the BCCI, ECB and Cricket Australia, had stalled both campaigns; the 2016 reversal of that restructuring under chairman Shashank Manohar reopened the path to expansion.

Build-Up

By early 2017, both boards had completed substantial governance, infrastructure and competition criteria reviews under the ICC's revised membership framework. The ICC Membership Committee, chaired by Imran Khwaja of Singapore, examined both applications against criteria covering domestic competition structures, women's cricket programmes, governance, financial reporting and infrastructure. Both applications were recommended for approval. The matter went to the ICC Full Council at the Oval in June 2017 for a final vote requiring a two-thirds majority. The vote was unanimous — every existing full member voted in favour — reflecting both the strength of the two applications and the broader political reset under Manohar's chairmanship. The decision took effect immediately and made Ireland the eleventh and Afghanistan the twelfth Test-playing nation, with both sides committed to playing inaugural Test matches in 2018.

What Happened

On June 22, 2017, the ICC announced that Ireland and Afghanistan had been granted Full Membership and Test status, becoming the 11th and 12th Test-playing nations. The decision was celebrated as a historic moment for cricket's expansion beyond its traditional strongholds. Ireland had been knocking on the door for years, with memorable World Cup victories over Pakistan (2007) and England (2011), while Afghanistan's remarkable rise from refugee camps to international cricket was one of sport's great stories.

However, the reality proved more challenging than the celebration suggested. Both nations struggled to schedule Test matches, with established teams reluctant to add fixtures to already crowded calendars. Ireland played just three Tests in their first three years as a Full Member. Afghanistan's situation was complicated further by the Taliban takeover in 2021, which ended women's cricket and raised questions about the country's continued membership.

Critics argued that Test status without guaranteed fixtures was a hollow gesture — the ICC had expanded the club without ensuring new members had meaningful access. The lack of a structured pathway for associate nations, combined with the scheduling dominance of the "Big Three," meant that Ireland and Afghanistan remained on the margins of Test cricket. The situation highlighted the gap between cricket's stated aspiration for global growth and the commercial realities that concentrated power and resources among a few wealthy boards.

Key Moments

1

ICC Full Council at the Oval votes unanimously to approve both applications on 22 June 2017

2

Afghanistan's inaugural Test against India at the M. Chinnaswamy Stadium in Bengaluru in June 2018

3

Ireland's inaugural Test against Pakistan at Malahide Cricket Club, Dublin, in May 2018

4

Both boards committing to women's cricket programmes as part of the membership framework

5

Subsequent struggles by both boards to secure regular Test fixtures against the established full members

6

Afghanistan's status placed under scrutiny following the Taliban takeover and ban on women's cricket from August 2021

7

The exclusion of both teams from the inaugural ICC World Test Championship cycle (2019-2021)

Timeline

1993

Ireland accepted as an Associate Member of the ICC

2001

Afghanistan admitted as an Affiliate Member of the ICC

2007

Ireland beat Pakistan at the World Cup in Jamaica

2014

ICC 'Big Three' restructuring stalls full member expansion

2016

Reversal of the Big Three structure under chairman Shashank Manohar reopens expansion path

Jun 22, 2017

ICC Full Council at the Oval votes unanimously to admit Ireland and Afghanistan as full members

May 2018

Ireland play inaugural Test against Pakistan at Malahide

Jun 2018

Afghanistan play inaugural Test against India at Bengaluru

Aug 2021

Taliban takeover of Afghanistan triggers ban on women's cricket and questions about full member status

2023

ICC working group convened to address compliance issues for Afghanistan

Notable Quotes

This is a great day for cricket in Ireland. We have worked for this for more than a decade. We will repay the faith shown in us by our fellow members.

Warren Deutrom, Cricket Ireland chief executive, after the vote

From the refugee camps of Pakistan to Test cricket in twenty years. This is the greatest day in the history of Afghan sport.

Atif Mashal, Afghanistan Cricket Board chairman, on the announcement

Today's decision marks a historic moment for our sport. The unanimous vote demonstrates the strength of both applications and the commitment of the cricket family to the growth of the game.

Shashank Manohar, ICC chairman, June 2017

Test status is wonderful, but Test status without Test matches is a hollow victory. We need a structured Future Tours Programme that gives us regular cricket against the established sides.

Cricket Ireland statement on the absence of regular Test fixtures, 2019

The ICC's constitution requires all full members to operate a women's cricket programme. The current situation in Afghanistan is incompatible with that requirement.

ICC working group on Afghanistan's full member status, 2023

Aftermath

The immediate aftermath of admission was substantially celebratory. Ireland's first Test at Malahide in May 2018, against Pakistan, drew strong domestic crowds and produced a competitive contest in which Ireland followed on but rallied to take the match into its fifth day before losing by five wickets. Afghanistan's first Test against India in Bengaluru in June 2018 was less competitive — they were beaten by an innings inside two days — but represented a milestone moment for a programme that had been operating from refugee camps in Pakistan less than two decades earlier. The longer-term challenges for both boards have been substantial. Neither was admitted to the inaugural ICC World Test Championship, the Test format's principal new structure, and both have struggled to secure regular Test fixtures against the established full members. Ireland played only nine Tests in the seven years following admission; Afghanistan played slightly more, but predominantly against other lower-tier full members. The financial economics of staging Tests — particularly without the broadcast revenues that follow series against India, England or Australia — have proved a serious obstacle for both boards.

⚖️ The Verdict

Test status was granted but meaningful access to Test cricket remained limited. The expansion exposed the gap between cricket's global ambitions and its commercial structure.

Legacy & Impact

The 2017 admissions are likely to remain the most significant Test-format expansion of the early twenty-first century. They established important governance precedents — particularly the requirement that all full members maintain women's cricket programmes — that have subsequently shaped the controversy over Afghanistan's status under Taliban rule. They demonstrated that the ICC could expand its full membership without the prolonged political bargaining that had characterised Bangladesh's elevation in 2000. They also exposed, however, the persistent gap between formal Test status and actual Test cricket: the absence of guaranteed fixtures, the structural exclusion of both new members from the WTC, and the financial unviability of staging Tests against lower-revenue opposition have meant that the practical benefits of full membership have been substantially less than the formal recognition implied. The Afghanistan case has, since 2021, become the principal pressure point in the wider debate about full member obligations: the ICC constitution requires all full members to maintain women's teams, and the Taliban's outright ban on women playing cricket has placed the Afghan board in formal breach of those requirements without prompting any sanction. The unresolved tension between the principle of expansion, the principle of compliance with membership criteria, and the geopolitical realities of administering cricket in regions of conflict will continue to define the legacy of the 2017 decisions.

Frequently Asked Questions

How did Ireland and Afghanistan qualify for full member status?
Both boards had completed extensive applications under the ICC's revised membership framework, which required compliance with criteria across domestic competition structure, women's cricket programmes, governance, financial reporting and infrastructure. The ICC Membership Committee, chaired by Imran Khwaja of Singapore, recommended both applications for approval. The matter went to the ICC Full Council at the Oval in June 2017, where every existing full member voted in favour — a unanimous decision that reflected the strength of both applications and the broader political reset following the rollback of the 2014 'Big Three' restructuring.
Why have Ireland and Afghanistan played so few Tests since admission?
Several structural factors. First, neither board was admitted to the inaugural ICC World Test Championship, the format's principal new structure, which has meant their Tests fall outside the main Test programme. Second, the financial economics of staging Tests are dependent on broadcast revenues that effectively only flow when India, England or Australia are touring; series between lower-revenue boards are not commercially viable in the same way. Third, the Future Tours Programme is negotiated on a bilateral basis between boards, and the established full members have been reluctant to commit to long Test series against the new full members at the expense of more lucrative fixtures elsewhere. Ireland played only nine Tests in the seven years following admission.
What is the controversy over Afghanistan's full member status?
The ICC constitution requires all full members to operate a women's cricket programme. Following the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan in August 2021, women in Afghanistan have been banned from playing cricket, and the contracted players of the Afghan women's team have been forced into exile, principally in Australia. This places the Afghan board in formal breach of the membership criteria. Despite this, the ICC has not formally suspended or downgraded Afghanistan's status, prompting an ongoing campaign — supported by Cricket Australia, several individual members and a number of human rights organisations — for stronger action.
Did the admissions affect the structure of the ICC?
Yes. The number of Test-playing full members rose from ten to twelve, increasing the size of the ICC Board and altering the calculations for the two-thirds majorities required for major constitutional decisions. The admissions also locked in the requirement, established under the revised membership framework, that all future full member applications must demonstrate compliance with women's cricket criteria — a requirement that has subsequently become significant in the Afghanistan controversy. The total number of ICC members across all categories also expanded as part of the same wider membership reform, which streamlined the previous Affiliate and Associate categories.
Are further Test-status admissions likely?
Not in the near term. The 2017 admissions exhausted the immediate pool of credible applicants under the revised membership framework. The leading current Associates — including Nepal, Scotland, the United States, the United Arab Emirates and the Netherlands — have made varying levels of progress in their domestic structures, women's cricket programmes and governance, but none has yet completed the application process or attracted the kind of cross-board political support that Ireland and Afghanistan secured in 2017. The financial difficulties experienced by Ireland and Afghanistan in actually playing regular Tests have also dampened enthusiasm at both the ICC and member-board level for further expansion in the short term.

Related Incidents

🔥Explosive

Bangladesh Refuses to Play T20 World Cup 2026 in India — The Full Story

Bangladesh vs ICC

7 February 2026

Bangladesh refused to play T20 World Cup 2026 in India and were replaced by Scotland after the ICC rejected their security-concern relocation demand.

#T20 World Cup 2026#Bangladesh#BCB
🔥Serious

South Africa and West Indies Stranded in India After T20 World Cup While England Flew Home — ICC Bias Row

South Africa, West Indies, England

10 March 2026

South Africa and West Indies stranded in India 8-11 days after T20 WC 2026 while England departed in 48 hours, sparking ICC bias claims.

#T20 World Cup 2026#South Africa#West Indies
🔥Moderate

Yuzvendra Chahal Allegedly Caught Vaping on Team Flight — Punjab Kings, IPL 2026

Punjab Kings

7 May 2026

Yuzvendra Chahal was allegedly captured vaping aboard a Punjab Kings team charter flight en route to Hyderabad ahead of the franchise's IPL 2026 match against Sunrisers Hyderabad on 6 May 2026. The footage surfaced from a behind-the-scenes vlog uploaded to social media by Chahal's PBKS teammate Arshdeep Singh, in which a figure appearing to be Chahal is visible with what observers identified as an electronic cigarette. The clip went viral within hours. Neither Chahal nor Arshdeep issued a public statement; Punjab Kings and the BCCI both remained silent. The controversy arrived just days after the BCCI had formally penalised Rajasthan Royals batter Riyan Parag for vaping in the team dressing room — and before the board had yet issued its blanket vaping ban for IPL venues.

#IPL 2026#Punjab Kings#Yuzvendra Chahal