Top Controversies

Ireland and Afghanistan Granted Test Status

22 June 2017Ireland and AfghanistanICC Full Membership Decision4 min readSeverity: Moderate

Summary

The ICC granted Full Membership and Test status to Ireland and Afghanistan in 2017, but the lack of guaranteed fixtures and the challenges of sustaining Test cricket raised questions about whether the expansion was genuine or merely symbolic.

Background

For most of cricket's history, the Test-playing group was a closed club of ten nations: England, Australia, South Africa, West Indies, New Zealand, India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Zimbabwe, and Bangladesh. Entry to the club was controlled by the ICC and effectively required the support of existing members, creating a barrier that associate nations found almost impossible to breach.

Ireland had been one of cricket's most successful associate nations for decades — a country with a small but passionate cricket community that had punched consistently above its weight. Their World Cup victories over Pakistan in 2007 and England in 2011 demonstrated that they could compete with the world's best on neutral territory. But Full Membership and Test status required more than on-field performance; it required ICC political will.

Afghanistan's story was entirely different — and even more remarkable. Cricket had spread to Afghan refugees in Pakistan during the 1980s and 1990s, taking root in camps along the Afghan-Pakistan border. The Afghan national team was established with almost no resources, progressing rapidly through the ICC's associate ranks on the strength of raw talent and an extraordinary will to succeed.

Build-Up

By 2016, both Ireland and Afghanistan were making sustained pushes for Full Membership. Ireland had finished as the top Associate nation in several ICC tournaments, qualified consistently for World Cups, and built professional domestic structures. Afghanistan had risen even faster, qualifying for the 2015 World Cup and producing world-class spin bowlers who were attracting IPL and county cricket interest.

The ICC's restructuring in 2017 — which saw the board reconstituted with representation from all member nations rather than being dominated by the Big Three — created the political environment in which expansion became possible. The new constitution included provisions for granting Full Membership based on criteria around governance, infrastructure, and competitive strength.

Both Ireland and Afghanistan applied formally and met the criteria. The ICC's vote in June 2017 was unanimous. Cricket had two new Test nations for the first time since Bangladesh's elevation in 2000.

What Happened

On June 22, 2017, the ICC announced that Ireland and Afghanistan had been granted Full Membership and Test status, becoming the 11th and 12th Test-playing nations. The decision was celebrated as a historic moment for cricket's expansion beyond its traditional strongholds. Ireland had been knocking on the door for years, with memorable World Cup victories over Pakistan (2007) and England (2011), while Afghanistan's remarkable rise from refugee camps to international cricket was one of sport's great stories.

However, the reality proved more challenging than the celebration suggested. Both nations struggled to schedule Test matches, with established teams reluctant to add fixtures to already crowded calendars. Ireland played just three Tests in their first three years as a Full Member. Afghanistan's situation was complicated further by the Taliban takeover in 2021, which ended women's cricket and raised questions about the country's continued membership.

Critics argued that Test status without guaranteed fixtures was a hollow gesture — the ICC had expanded the club without ensuring new members had meaningful access. The lack of a structured pathway for associate nations, combined with the scheduling dominance of the "Big Three," meant that Ireland and Afghanistan remained on the margins of Test cricket. The situation highlighted the gap between cricket's stated aspiration for global growth and the commercial realities that concentrated power and resources among a few wealthy boards.

Key Moments

1

Ireland defeat Pakistan in 2007 World Cup and England in 2011 World Cup, establishing credentials for Full Membership

2

Afghanistan progress through ICC associate ranks at extraordinary speed, qualifying for 2015 and 2019 World Cups

3

ICC governance reforms in 2017 create political conditions for Full Membership expansion

4

June 22, 2017: ICC grants Full Membership and Test status to Ireland and Afghanistan simultaneously

5

Ireland play their inaugural Test against Pakistan in May 2018; Kevin O'Brien and others make history

6

Taliban takeover of Afghanistan in 2021 ends women's cricket; ICC faces pressure over Afghanistan's continued membership

Timeline

2007

Ireland defeat Pakistan in ICC World Cup — a landmark moment for Associate cricket

2011

Ireland defeat England in ICC World Cup; Afghanistan reach World Cup for first time in 2015

2017 (January)

ICC governance reforms create new Full Member criteria framework

June 22, 2017

ICC grants Full Membership and Test status to Ireland and Afghanistan

May 2018

Ireland play their inaugural Test match against Pakistan in Malahide, Dublin

August 2021

Taliban takeover ends women's cricket in Afghanistan; ICC membership status questioned

Notable Quotes

This is the proudest day in Irish cricket's history. We have worked for this for decades.

Cricket Ireland CEO Warren Deutrom, June 2017

Afghanistan's journey is one of sport's great stories. From refugee camps to Test cricket in one generation.

ICC Chairman Shashank Manohar, 2017

Test status means nothing if we can't actually play Tests. We need fixtures, not just a title.

Ireland cricketer (widely reported sentiment, post-2018)

The ICC cannot ignore what is happening to women's cricket in Afghanistan. Membership comes with obligations.

Women's cricket advocate, 2022

Aftermath

The celebrations of June 2017 quickly gave way to harder realities. Both nations struggled to schedule Test matches, with the existing Full Members reluctant to disrupt their own bilateral schedules for fixtures against Ireland and Afghanistan. The WTC structure, while helping to formalise the Test calendar, did not guarantee Ireland and Afghanistan a full schedule of competitive matches.

Afghanistan's situation deteriorated dramatically after the Taliban seized power in August 2021. Women's cricket was banned — a direct breach of ICC membership criteria, which require member nations to support cricket for all genders. The ICC faced a painful choice between upholding its own rules and maintaining cricket's presence in Afghanistan, ultimately deferring action in a way that disappointed many in the game.

⚖️ The Verdict

Test status was granted but meaningful access to Test cricket remained limited. The expansion exposed the gap between cricket's global ambitions and its commercial structure.

Legacy & Impact

Ireland's Test status has proven more sustainable. They have built a competitive Test team, played fixtures against several Full Members, and demonstrated that a small nation with strong governance can succeed at the highest level. Their story is an unambiguous success for cricket's expansion.

Afghanistan's legacy is more complex. Their male cricketers have become genuine world-class players — their spin attack is among the best in the world. But the political situation overshadowing their cricket means that the 2017 grant of Test status will be remembered as much for its complications as its celebration. The ICC's handling of Afghanistan's governance issues remains a live and unresolved controversy.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why were Ireland and Afghanistan granted Test status in 2017?
Both nations had demonstrated sustained on-field success, strong governance structures, and genuine cricket infrastructure. ICC governance reforms in 2017 created clearer criteria for Full Membership, and both nations met them.
Have Ireland and Afghanistan played many Tests?
Ireland has played a modest but growing number of Tests. Afghanistan has played more, often hosting in neutral venues. Both have struggled to secure a full schedule against established Test nations.
What is the controversy around Afghanistan's ICC membership?
The Taliban government's ban on women's cricket from 2021 violates ICC membership criteria requiring cricket to be accessible to all genders. The ICC has been criticised for not taking stronger action against Afghanistan's membership.
Was the expansion of Test cricket a success?
For Ireland, broadly yes. For Afghanistan, the on-field story is positive but the political situation is deeply problematic. The episode showed that granting Test status without guaranteed fixtures or political safeguards creates as many problems as it solves.
Who were the first nations to get Test status before Ireland and Afghanistan?
Bangladesh were the most recent before the 2017 expansion, gaining Test status in 2000. Zimbabwe got Test status in 1992. All other Test-playing nations had been members for decades.

Related Incidents