England, batting first, made 404 (Hutton 196). West Indies replied with 277. Headley, batting at three, made 106 in his first innings: orthodox driving, late cuts, the cover stroke that he played late and with a high front elbow. The crowd, which had come to see Hutton, stayed for him.
England declared at 5 for 128 in the second innings, setting West Indies an overnight target. Headley, walking in at 1 for 18, batted for nearly four hours and made 107. He lost partners — JET Barrow caught at slip, Stollmeyer bowled, Constantine yorked — but kept attacking, hitting 11 fours and one six. He was sixth out for 107 with the chase still hopeless; West Indies fell for 225 chasing 277. England won by eight wickets.
The twin centuries made Headley the first batsman to score two centuries in a Test at Lord's, a record Bradman never matched, and only the second to do so in a Test in England (after the same Headley in 1930 at Bourda — he had now done it on three occasions, more than anyone in history at that point). 'The Black Bradman' tag, never one Headley enjoyed, became unavoidable: Caribbean papers had taken to calling Bradman 'the white Headley.'