Mumbai Indians' decision to replace Rohit Sharma — their five-title-winning captain — with Hardik Pandya triggered one of the most sustained fan backlashes in IPL history, as Pandya was booed relentlessly throughout IPL 2024 while Rohit batted for the same team.
In January 2024, Mumbai Indians announced that Hardik Pandya — re-acquired from Gujarat Titans in a blockbuster transfer — would captain the franchise for IPL 2024. The decision required stripping Rohit Sharma of the captaincy he had held since 2013 and with which he had delivered five IPL titles.
The public reaction was swift and visceral. Rohit Sharma was among India's most beloved cricket figures — not just a great captain but a fan favourite across the country. His five IPL titles, delivered with an attacking style and personal warmth, had made him synonymous with Mumbai Indians' identity. The franchise's decision was seen not as a tactical choice but as a betrayal.
Pandya — talented, certainly, but seen by many as the agent of Rohit's removal — became the target of the fans' fury. Every IPL 2024 home game at Wankhede became a sustained exercise in crowd rejection. Pandya was booed on the toss, booed when fielding, booed when bowling, booed when batting. The sound was consistent and organised — not the spontaneous jeering of a bad performance but deliberate, sustained rejection.
Meanwhile, Rohit — still playing for Mumbai as a batsman — received the reception of a king every time he appeared. The contrast was comically stark: the captain was booed, the former captain was adored, both in the same XI.
Mumbai Indians had their worst IPL season in years. By the end of 2024, the decision had been effectively reversed: Rohit Sharma was reinstated as MI captain for IPL 2025, and Pandya returned to being a senior player without the captaincy.
Mumbai Indians announce Pandya as captain — Rohit stripped of captaincy
Fan backlash immediate and enormous across social media
IPL 2024 Wankhede: Pandya booed at toss
Every Pandya action on field met with boos — Rohit's every touch met with cheers
MI finish IPL 2024 with poor record
Rohit reinstated as captain for IPL 2025
“I understand the situation. Rohit is a legend here. My job is to perform and help the team win. The noise doesn't change what I'm trying to do.”
“I don't have any say in franchise decisions. I'll give everything for Mumbai whenever I play. That doesn't change.”
The IPL 2024 captaincy controversy became one of the tournament's defining stories — not because of cricket but because of fan power. Mumbai Indians' reversal in 2025 was widely read as an acknowledgement that the franchise had misjudged the strength of feeling.
Pandya captained MI through IPL 2024. MI had their worst season in years. Rohit was reinstated as captain for IPL 2025. The episode became a case study in franchise decisions conflicting with fan sentiment.
Australia vs England
2 December 1932
England captain Douglas Jardine devised the 'Bodyline' strategy of fast, short-pitched bowling aimed at the batsman's body to neutralize Don Bradman, nearly causing a diplomatic crisis between England and Australia.
Multiple (WSC vs Establishment Cricket)
24 November 1977
Media mogul Kerry Packer signed 51 of the world's best cricketers to a rival competition after being denied TV broadcast rights, fundamentally transforming professional cricket.
South Africa vs England/Sri Lanka/West Indies/Australia rebel XIs
6 March 1982
Multiple international teams sent unofficial rebel squads to play in apartheid-era South Africa, leading to lengthy bans for participating players and deepening cricket's political fault lines.