Pilch was a Norfolk-born professional who had been engaged by Thomas Selby, the proprietor of the Town Malling ground, to play for Kent on a reputed retainer of £100 a year. By 1841 he was 38 and at the peak of his powers; his upright forward play and command of length bowling had been the model for a generation of batsmen. The Town Malling fixture of 1841 brought him face to face with the strongest England side of the day, including the slow underarm bowler William Lillywhite and the fast roundarmer Sam Redgate. Kent batted first, lost early wickets, and saw Pilch come in at three. He made 153 not out from a total of around 280, batting through the innings and treating bowling that had dismissed everyone else with the calm forward defence that Nyren had identified ten years earlier as 'the model of all batting'. The innings stood for several years as the highest score in a leading match. Kent won by an innings, the high point of the brief Town Malling era before Canterbury Week superseded it.