The decision was made before the series even ended. After the Tied Test at Brisbane, with crowds returning in numbers Australian cricket had not seen for years, Bradman pushed the board to formalise the contest. McCormick — who had taken 36 wickets for Australia between 1935 and 1938 before retraining as a jeweller in Melbourne — was given the commission. He produced a silver trophy topped by a globe, designed to be presented to the winning captain at the end of every Australia v West Indies series.
The trophy was first presented at the end of the fifth Test in Melbourne, which Australia won by two wickets to take the series 2-1. Worrell, defeated, handed the trophy to Benaud. Both men were photographed laughing. Two days later, Melbourne's city authorities organised a ticker-tape parade for the West Indians as they drove from the team hotel to a civic reception at Town Hall. The estimate of half a million in attendance has been disputed since but never seriously revised; the parade was, by every contemporary account, the largest Melbourne had seen for any sporting visitor.
That the trophy was named for the losing captain has always carried weight. Worrell himself reportedly suggested it be named for Bradman; Bradman declined and insisted on Worrell.