Allan was 27, a Crown Lands officer at Warrnambool in western Victoria, and the most feared bowler in the colonies. He was a left-arm medium-pacer with a peculiar swerve, and his career analysis at intercolonial level — 83 wickets at 11.98 — would be the equal of any contemporary. He had agreed to play for Australia in March 1877, but two days before the start sent a telegram saying he had to remain in Warrnambool because it was carnival week and 'I expect to meet many friends I have not seen for a long time'. The selectors, dismayed, replaced him at the last moment with the Tasmanian Tom Kendall, who took 7/55 and won the match. Allan eventually made his only Test appearance in January 1879 against Lord Harris's tourists, taking 4/80. W.G. Grace later said Allan was the most difficult bowler he ever faced. The Warrnambool excuse — possibly the most genteel withdrawal in Test history — has remained a quirk of cricket folklore.