Bannerman had opened the batting for the All-Australian XI alongside Nat Thompson. Thompson fell early to Allen Hill for one. Thereafter Bannerman dominated. He was strong off the back foot and on the drive, and the English attack — Shaw, Hill, Lillywhite, Southerton and Ulyett — had no answer on the firm MCG pitch. He brought up the first Test fifty before lunch on day one and the first Test hundred during the afternoon session, off Alfred Shaw. He was eventually forced to retire on 165 when a delivery from George Ulyett split the index finger of his right hand. He had batted for 285 minutes, hit 18 fours, and faced — by reconstructed estimates — about 165 four-ball overs. The next-highest score in Australia's 245 was 18, by wicketkeeper Jack Blackham. Bannerman's share of his side's total — 67.34% — has never been bettered by any Test centurion in nearly 150 years.