The fixture had been agreed earlier in the summer through correspondence between the Toronto Cricket Club and the St George's Cricket Club of New York. Each side fielded eleven players. Canada batted first and made 82, with the New York-born George Wheatcroft bowling well for the United States; the United States replied with 64. Canada's second innings yielded 63, and the United States, set 82 to win, were dismissed for 58. The Canadian bowler David Winckworth took a haul of wickets across the two innings and was the player most commonly identified as the match-winner. The crowd, estimated at between 5,000 and 8,000 across the two days, included gamblers from both cities; contemporary newspapers reported that the wagering on the match exceeded $100,000 in side bets, an extraordinary sum for the period. The match was played on the St George's Cricket Club's ground at the corner of 30th Street and 1st Avenue (then on the outskirts of New York), an area developed for sport in the 1830s and 1840s.