Lord Harris won the toss for England and put Australia in. Percy McDonnell made 103, Murdoch came in at 158/2 and stayed all the way to 502/4, batting through two days. He was 145 not out at the end of the first day, then resumed on the second to break Charles Bannerman's old Test record (165*) before reaching 200. He was eventually out for 211, caught at the wicket; he had been dropped at 46, 171 and 205, all by Ulyett.
Murdoch's stand of 207 with Tup Scott (102) was the first double-century partnership in Test cricket. Australia's eventual 551 was 100 runs more than any previous Test innings total.
When the regular bowlers ran out of ideas, Lord Harris called on his entire side. Wicketkeeper Lyttelton, an Eton-and-Cambridge amateur with no first-class wickets to his name, padded up his pads and bowled underhand lobs from the Pavilion End. WG Grace, also an irregular bowler, kept wicket. Lyttelton's figures of 4 for 19 — including Midwinter, caught Grace in the keeper's gloves — were the best of the innings; he is still the only player in international cricket history to take a four-wicket haul while playing as a wicketkeeper.
England made 346, followed on, and reached 85/2 when time ran out. Match drawn. Murdoch's 211 stood as the highest individual Test score until Tip Foster's 287 at Sydney in 1903.