Bates was an off-break bowler with a quick arm and a flat trajectory — a true Yorkshire pro of his era, not a flighter. He had taken 6/68 in the first innings to bowl Australia out for 132. England replied with 294, a lead of 162.
In the second innings Bates settled into a long spell from the southern end. He had Percy McDonnell caught by WG (a substitute fielder, since this was Bligh's privately-raised side), then bowled the all-rounder George Giffen for a duck, and then trapped Bonnor — Australia's six-foot-six giant — leg before with the next ball. Three Australian wickets in three balls.
He finished with 7/74 in the second innings and match figures of 14/102. England won by an innings and 27 runs. The match was also the first Test won by Bligh's tour and the start of the comeback that would take the official series to 2-1.
Bates also made 55 with the bat, becoming the first bowler in Test history to take ten wickets and score a half-century in the same match. The Australian press, which had largely written off Bligh's side after the first-Test defeat, gave him column inches usually reserved for Spofforth.